The Market Is Deciding This, Not the ALA, PW, B&N, Indie Booksellers, etc...

Tick Tock

Scroll down and look at the topics of the other posts on this blog. Libraries kowtow to Overdrive, which in turn kowtows to the Big 6 5. Indie Bookstores don't accept innovative ideas, and instead, cling to the idea that "there isn't enough room, we can return big publisher's books," etc. Please, take a look at my suggestion below, made to independent bookstores: take a free copy from a self-published author as a "store copy," which can be ordered from your store with NO RISK. Barnes & Noble can't do this because the book needs to registered in their in-store system (also illogical since my book is available on bn.com and in Nook format).  Remember Nook?

Amazon and Now Oyster

Amazon Prime can easily be modified/enhanced to include book. Oyster is a new startup, and has the right idea: it has signed up Smashwords. So for one fee, you can borrow an ebook. The selection will naturally be MUCH MUCH MUCH wider than that available at libraries, that have kowtowed to the Big 5 and Overdrive. Many libraries rely on PW, Booklist, NYT Book Review, etc as the sole source of information, which in turn are funded by the Big 5.
Who is to blame? Not individual libraries or individual librarians. It is the management of the ALA. PERIOD. If you pontificate too long, the market decides for you: you are not the only smart person in the room. And that person may know someone with money to post to fight the illogic. Meet Jeff Bezos, and now, another new entrant.
Who wants to bet on which party responds first? Amazon or Libraries. Oops: I get to take Amazon. You can have the field.

Libraries, ebooks and Book Publishers

Aren't You a Little Embarrassed?

This is almost comical, really.

a. Big publishers charge libraries a much, much higher price for a single copy of an ebook.

b. Libraries deploy Overdrive.

c. Overdrive only really uses the big publishers.

d. The big publishers have high barriers to entry for authors/content.

e. Libraries complain about access to content.

You can "yabit" all you would like: now you are the Big 3 per the first entry on this blog. Meanwhile, amazon.com is just distributing all around you, and if you don't watch it, amazon could relax the Kindle lending program, and then what will you say?  

The Real Problem? Point C: Overdrive

Using Overdrive is like sleeping with the enemy. Hasn't the book publishing/distribution industry learned anything? The oligopoly is being challenged at every turn by amazon, which has capital to exploit every inefficiency. Let's be clear: Overdrive uses the big publishers, the very same ones that are charging libraries many times more than it charges consumers on amazon.com. That consumer can now lend that copy to a friend for free using Amazon Prime. The barrier for establishing "Jae's Public Library" on amazon.com? Almost none. Libraries will need to challenge Overdrive on this practice and right now. Otherwise, you will have empowered the big publishing houses, not challenged them. Any little leverage libraries have remaining? Dust.

ALA Isn't Innocent
Read the annual letter from the ALA president, which sets the priority of ebooks and libraries on negotiating with the Big 6 publishers. THIS IS A DOOMED STRATEGY. Libraries do not have the requisite LEVERAGE to exert influence on the "negotiation." So, library systems are purporting to offer ebooks via Overdrive, and around we go again, in the profoundly irrational manner that currently exists.

At Least SOMEONE Gets It

If you think that I am just criticizing for fun, you're wrong. I am writing this because I would rather see libraries survive. At least Douglas County CO understands the depth of the issue, and doing something. Read this article. Mr LaRue is right: libraries are getting the short end of the stick by all its suppliers. Look at the list a-e. Book publishers, and Overdrive combine to make the availability of content to your patrons difficult. I can tell you that it is almost impossible to offer my top-selling book on Medicare via Overdrive. There is almost no defensible reason for this.

Baker and Taylor Axis360, however is different: Smashwords can supply to Axis360 if the author chooses, and a library can use Baker and Taylor's platform to order a Smashwords' produced ebook. Here is an example: my book is offered here via Axis360 at the Eastern Monore Public Library.

Book Publishers Are Doing What Oligopolists Do

Just understand the phrase, "Where you stand depends on where you sit," a phrase I read as a youth in Graham T. Allison's Essence of Decision (awesome book). Libraries will need simple market forces to bring prices lower; DCL and Axis360 or similar platform are the way forward. Now the challenge is getting the right information into hands of the libraries so they know about books. Library Journal, Booklist, Publishers Weekly, New York Times Book Review, right?
LOL: there is another list like the one in the first paragraph, but that is for the next post.